Overview
58 links in one network
Each dot is an indicator, coloured by where it stands this issue; bigger dots are involved in more links. Each line runs from cause to effect, in the direction of the common explanation. The thick brass lines are the 24 links lit this issue (one end at a historical extreme). Hover over an indicator (tap on a phone) to see only its links; click a line to see how that link was tested.
Dots = indicators, colored by this issue’s reading:coldcoolneutralwarmhotBigger dot = more linksFaded = not lit this issue
Lines = links (arrows follow the common explanation’s direction):Supported by the dataWeak or inconsistentNot visible in our data, or our data show the oppositeLit up this issue
Supported by the data
Supported by the data (22)
Agreement of 0.4 or more, and in step in at least 75% of 5-year periods.
- Real ratetoUS 10-yr yieldCommon explanation: Cause · same direction10-year yield = real rate + inflation expectations (an identity)Agreement +0.91 · in step in 9 of 9 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- US 10-yr yieldtoGerman 10-yr yieldCommon explanation: Ripple · same directionGlobal investors compare government bonds across countries, so rising US yields pull others alongAgreement +0.85 · in step in 12 of 12 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- US stockstoWorld stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · same directionThe US is the world’s largest stock market, and US corrections often spill over to other markets; in a crisis, markets everywhere fall togetherAgreement +0.77 · in step in 45 of 45 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Taiwan export orderstoTaiwan cycle signalCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionExport orders lead exports and production, and the business cycle signal followsAgreement +0.65 · in step in 17 of 17 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- US stockstoTaiwan stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · same directionElectronics and semiconductors make up a large share of Taiwan’s market, which moves closely with US stocksAgreement +0.62 · in step in 14 of 15 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Expected inflationtoUS 10-yr yieldCommon explanation: Cause · same direction10-year yield = real rate + the inflation markets expect (an identity)Agreement +0.59 · in step in 7 of 9 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Taiwan export orderstoTaiwan stocksCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionExport orders and share prices are both leading indicators, turning before the economy doesAgreement +0.59 · in step in 15 of 15 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Supply pressuretoUS inflationCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionClogged supply chains and higher freight costs make goods cost moreAgreement +0.45 · in step in 14 of 14 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Leading indextoCopperCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionExpanding manufacturing needs more copperAgreement +0.44 · in step in 40 of 42 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- USD/CNYtoChina stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · renminbi weakens, China stocks fallSharp swings in Chinese stocks can fuel capital outflows, and outflows put pressure on the renminbi (the source discusses 2015–16)Agreement +0.78 · in step in 3 of 3 5-year periods
- Fed funds ratetoYield curveCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionRate hikes lift short-term rates first, flattening or inverting the curveAgreement +0.77 · in step in 46 of 48 5-year periods
- ConfidencetoLeading indexCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionBusiness and consumer confidence surveys pick up turning points in the economy early, moving with the leading indexAgreement +0.77 · in step in 36 of 36 5-year periods
- US dollartoCommoditiesCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionCommodities are priced in dollars, so a strong dollar raises their cost for other countries and demand falls; from 2021, though, the two moved together for a timeAgreement +0.68 · in step in 7 of 8 5-year periods
- Leading indextoIndustrial outputCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionOrders and confidence move first, and production adjusts afterAgreement +0.66 · in step in 10 of 10 5-year periods
- US dollartoEmerging marketsCommon explanation: Ripple · opposite directionA strong dollar makes emerging economies’ dollar debts heavier, drives money out and tightens financial conditionsAgreement +0.56 · in step in 5 of 5 5-year periods
- US inflationtoPolicy ratesCommon explanation: Cause · same directionWhen a country’s inflation is above target, its central bank raises ratesAgreement +0.54 · in step in 14 of 14 5-year periods
- US inflationtoFed funds rateCommon explanation: Cause · same directionWhen inflation is above target, the central bank raises rates to cool demandAgreement +0.53 · in step in 37 of 48 5-year periods
- OiltoUS inflationCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionEnergy is part of consumer prices and a cost of transport and productionAgreement +0.53 · in step in 38 of 42 5-year periods
- Nonfarm payrollstoUnemploymentCommon explanation: Knock-on · opposite directionWhen job growth slows, the unemployment rate risesAgreement +0.50 · in step in 49 of 54 5-year periods
- OFR stresstoWorld stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · opposite directionWhen financial stress and volatility jump, funds that control risk by volatility lower their stock holdings at the same time, putting pressure on stock marketsAgreement +0.50 · in step in 12 of 12 5-year periods
- Financial stresstoWorld stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · opposite directionIn a panic, the prices of risky assets of all kinds tend to fall togetherAgreement +0.48 · in step in 28 of 32 5-year periods
- Philly FedtoIndustrial outputCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionThe new orders and shipments that manufacturers report lead actual productionAgreement +0.45 · in step in 10 of 10 5-year periods
Weak or inconsistent
Weak or inconsistent (20)
Over the whole history the direction matches the common explanation, but the link is weak (agreement 0.1–0.4) or unstable (in step in fewer than 75% of 5-year periods): it holds in some eras and not in others.
- USD/JPYtoJapan stocksCommon explanation: Cause · yen strengthens, Japan stocks fallA stronger yen squeezes exporters’ profits in yen termsAgreement +0.59 · in step in 19 of 31 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Credit spreadtoUS stocksCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionA wider credit spread means costlier funding and higher default risk for companies, weighing on share pricesAgreement +0.47 · in step in 24 of 39 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Policy ratestoGerman 10-yr yieldCommon explanation: Cause · same directionPolicy rates set the short end and pull long-term rates along (ECB → German bonds)Agreement +0.40 · in step in 6 of 12 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- US 10-yr yieldtoUS valuationCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionHigher rates make future profits worth less today, weighing on valuationsAgreement +0.37 · in step in 24 of 49 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- German 10-yr yieldtoEUR/USDCommon explanation: Cause · euro strengthensWhen European rates rise relative to US rates, money flows into the euroAgreement +0.35 · in step in 0 of 3 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Industrial outputtoCopperCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionMore production uses more metalAgreement +0.31 · in step in 9 of 10 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- USD/JPYtoWorld stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · a sharp rise in the yen weighs on world stocksPositions funded in yen are forced to unwind together, and stock markets around the world come under pressure at the same timeAgreement +0.13 · in step in 18 of 31 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Core inflationtoFed funds rateCommon explanation: Cause · same directionThe Fed’s 2% target is set for overall prices, but it uses core inflation, which excludes food and energy, to judge the trendAgreement +0.65 · in step in 31 of 44 5-year periods
- WagestoCore inflationCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionServices rely mostly on labor, so wages push up service pricesAgreement +0.46 · in step in 22 of 37 5-year periods
- Natural gastoEuro-area stocksCommon explanation: Knock-on · opposite directionSoaring energy costs squeeze European manufacturers’ profits, especially in energy-intensive industries, most visibly in 2022; but where firms can pass costs on, share prices do not necessarily fallAgreement +0.41 · in step in 10 of 16 5-year periods
- Natural gastoUS inflationCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionNatural gas drives electricity and heating bills (most clearly in Europe)Agreement +0.39 · in step in 25 of 42 5-year periods
- Leading indextoGDP growthCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionThe leading index combines short-term series that turn before the economy does, so its turning points usually come a few months before GDP’s (the OECD aims for a 6–9 month lead)Agreement +0.39 · in step in 11 of 11 5-year periods
- Food pricestoUS inflationCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionFood prices push up food inflation (food weighs heavily in emerging economies)Agreement +0.32 · in step in 26 of 42 5-year periods
- Philly FedtoLeading indexCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionBusiness surveys are among the earliest signals of where the economy is headingAgreement +0.31 · in step in 42 of 44 5-year periods
- UnemploymenttoFed funds rateCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionWhen unemployment rises, the central bank cuts rates to support jobs (its dual mandate)Agreement +0.30 · in step in 43 of 48 5-year periods
- Financial stresstoGoldCommon explanation: Ripple · same directionIn a panic, safe-haven demand flows into goldAgreement +0.25 · in step in 17 of 32 5-year periods
- Leading indextoGerman stocksCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionGermany relies on export manufacturing and is deeply embedded in global supply chains, so global demand directly affects its exports and investmentAgreement +0.24 · in step in 34 of 42 5-year periods
- Yield curvetoLeading indexCommon explanation: Cause · same directionAn inverted curve usually signals tight monetary policy and expected rate cuts, and the economy weakens afterwards; inversions have often come before recessionsAgreement +0.22 · in step in 28 of 51 5-year periods
- Fed funds ratetoNet share hikingCommon explanation: Ripple · same directionOnce the Fed changes course, other central banks often followAgreement +0.19 · in step in 36 of 47 5-year periods
- OiltoIndia stocksCommon explanation: Knock-on · opposite directionIndia is a net oil importer, so rising oil prices squeeze its economy and its currencyAgreement +0.19 · in step in 17 of 42 5-year periods
Not visible in our data
Not visible in our data (12)
The common explanation gives a reason, but over the whole history our data do not show the two positions moving together (agreement between −0.3 and 0.1). A few move in step within every 5-year period, yet their highs and lows do not line up over the whole history, so they still count as not visible.
- Lending standardstoCredit spreadCommon explanation: Cause · same directionWhen banks tighten lending, borrowing becomes harder and costlier for companiesAgreement +0.09 · in step in 3 of 4 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Fed assetstoUS stocksCommon explanation: Cause · same directionLarge Fed bond purchases push down long-term rates, investors move the money from the bonds they sell into stocks and other assets, and stock prices get supportAgreement +0.06 · in step in 6 of 8 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Japan 10-yr yieldtoUSD/JPYCommon explanation: Cause · yen strengthensRising Japanese rates make borrowing yen to invest costlier, so money flows back to JapanAgreement −0.06 · in step in 10 of 16 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- USD/TWDtoTaiwan stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · Taiwan dollar strengthens, Taiwan stocks riseForeign money flowing in lifts both the Taiwan dollar and Taiwan stocksAgreement +0.03 · in step in 14 of 15 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Leading indextoUS stocksCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionStrong economy → company profits → share pricesAgreement −0.03 · in step in 34 of 51 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Credit spreadtoLeading indexCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionTighter credit holds back investment and hiringAgreement −0.02 · in step in 20 of 39 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- US dollartoUSD/CNYCommon explanation: Ripple · renminbi weakensWhen the dollar strengthens, the renminbi comes under pressureAgreement −0.18 · in step in 5 of 8 5-year periods
- Bond volatilitytoWorld stocksCommon explanation: Ripple · opposite directionWhen rates swing widely, discount rates for all assets become unstable, and risky assets come under pressure togetherAgreement −0.15 · in step in 35 of 45 5-year periods
- Financial stresstoUS dollarCommon explanation: Ripple · same directionIn a panic, money rushes into the dollar for safetyAgreement +0.10 · in step in 8 of 8 5-year periods
- Leading indextoWorld stocksCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionStrong global economy → company profits everywhere → world share pricesAgreement +0.08 · in step in 33 of 45 5-year periods
- US dollartoUSD/TWDCommon explanation: Ripple · Taiwan dollar weakensWhen the dollar strengthens, foreign money flows out of TaiwanAgreement +0.04 · in step in 8 of 8 5-year periods
- US 10-yr yieldtoHouse prices, 8 economiesCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionRising mortgage rates weigh on house pricesAgreement +0.01 · in step in 1 of 8 5-year periods
Our data show the opposite
Our data show the opposite (4)
Over the whole history, our data move in the opposite direction to the common economic explanation (agreement below −0.3; sources are on each link’s page), though some 5-year periods may still be in step. We list these in full rather than removing them.
- US 10-yr yieldtoUS dollarCommon explanation: Cause · same directionWhen US rates are relatively high, money flows into dollar assetsAgreement −0.64 · in step in 3 of 8 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- Real ratetoGoldCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionGold pays no interest, so the higher the real rate, the higher the opportunity cost of holding goldAgreement −0.44 · in step in 7 of 9 5-year periodsLit up this issue
- EUR/USDtoEuro-area stocksCommon explanation: Cause · opposite directionA stronger euro erodes exporters’ price competitiveness and profits, which weighs on export stocks; but the broad market is driven by other factors tooAgreement −0.74 · in step in 0 of 3 5-year periods
- OiltoUK stocksCommon explanation: Knock-on · same directionEnergy and materials shares weigh heavily in the UK marketAgreement −0.47 · in step in 23 of 42 5-year periods
Compounding
Compounding and offsetting
Common economic explanations describe some pairs as reinforcing each other (compounding) or pulling against each other (offsetting). We look only at the data: a pair lights up this issue only when both indicators are at the named end; for the rest, this issue’s positions are listed. How often the same combination appeared in the past, and what followed, is listed as the data show.
- US valuation × Credit spreadCompoundingUS valuation at the high end × credit spread at the high endNot lit this issue: US valuation at 99, Credit spread at 9
- Yield curve × Leading indexCompoundingYield curve at the low end × leading index at the low endNot lit this issue: Yield curve at 41, Leading index at 42
- US dollar × Emerging marketsCompoundingUS dollar at the high end × emerging markets at the high endNot lit this issue: US dollar at 45, Emerging markets at 53
- Oil × US inflationCompoundingOil at the high end × US inflation at the high endNot lit this issue: Oil at 72, US inflation at 64
- US margin loans × Financial stressCompoundingMargin debt at the high end × financial stress at the high endNot lit this issue: US margin loans at 88, Financial stress at 12
- Real rate × GoldCompoundingReal rate at the high end × gold at the high endNot lit this issue: Real rate at 100, Gold at 84
- Fed funds rate × Leading indexOffsettingFed funds rate at the high end × leading index at the high endNot lit this issue: Fed funds rate at 72, Leading index at 42
- US dollar × Real rateOffsettingUS dollar at the high end × real rate at the low endNot lit this issue: US dollar at 45, Real rate at 100
Method
How links are tested
- Using the time lag given in the common explanation (for “0–12 months”, the midpoint of 6 months), we compute the correlation between the two positions (−1 to +1). When the common explanation runs the opposite way (one high, the other low), we flip the sign and call it “agreement”: +1 means they always move together the way the common explanation says.
- We look at every 5-year period, shifted one year at a time, and count how many are in step; runs of years that are out of step are listed in full. The agreement over the whole history and the result for each period can differ: two series can move together within every 5 years while their highs and lows do not line up over the whole history. The groups are based mainly on the agreement over the whole history; “supported by the data” also requires at least 75% of periods to be in step.
- When two indicators move together only because the same cause drives both (a common source), we do not draw a link.